Research & Resources

The Science of Meditation & Breathwork: What the Research Says

Curated, plain-language summaries of key studies on two practices at the heart of iSpiro: meditation and breathwork.

Part 1

Meditation

Meditation has been studied in hundreds of clinical trials. Below is a curated selection of key studies and reviews, grouped by area of benefit. Each entry includes a short plain-language summary and a link to the paper (free full text where available).

Stress, Anxiety & Mood

Meditation Programs for Psychological Stress and Well-being

Goyal et al. · JAMA Internal Medicine · 2014

A Johns Hopkins review that pooled 47 randomized trials with active control groups (3,515 participants). It found moderate evidence that meditation programs improve anxiety, depression and pain. Meditation was not shown to be better than other active treatments such as medication or exercise, but it compared well as an option.

Read the paper (PDF)(opens in a new tab)

Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction vs Escitalopram for Anxiety Disorders

Hoge et al. · JAMA Psychiatry · 2023

276 adults with anxiety disorders were randomly assigned to an 8-week mindfulness course (MBSR) or the antidepressant escitalopram (Lexapro). The mindfulness program performed as well as the medication. It was the first trial to compare a mindfulness program directly against a first-line anxiety drug.

Read the paper (PDF)(opens in a new tab)

Brief Structured Respiration Practices Enhance Mood and Reduce Physiological Arousal

Balban et al. · Cell Reports Medicine · 2023

A Stanford study comparing three daily 5-minute breathing exercises with 5 minutes of mindfulness meditation over one month. Both breathwork and meditation improved mood and lowered anxiety. Breathwork, especially “cyclic sighing” (a double inhale followed by a long exhale), produced the bigger improvement in mood and the larger drop in breathing rate.

Read the paper(opens in a new tab)

Depression

Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy in Prevention of Depressive Relapse

Kuyken et al. · JAMA Psychiatry · 2016

A meta-analysis of individual patient data from 1,258 people with a history of recurrent depression. Within about 14 months, 38% of people who took MBCT relapsed, compared with 49% of those who did not. MBCT also outperformed maintenance antidepressants alone, with a 23% lower relapse risk.

Read the paper(opens in a new tab)

Sleep

Mindfulness Meditation and Improvement in Sleep Quality Among Older Adults

Black et al. · JAMA Internal Medicine · 2015

Older adults with moderate sleep problems took either a 6-week mindfulness program or a sleep-hygiene education course. The mindfulness group saw a larger improvement in sleep quality, with a large effect size. They also had greater reductions in insomnia symptoms, fatigue and depression symptoms.

Read the paper(opens in a new tab)

Pain

Mindfulness Meditation for Chronic Pain: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Hilton et al. · Annals of Behavioral Medicine · 2017

A RAND Corporation review of 38 randomized trials in people with chronic pain. Mindfulness meditation was linked to a small reduction in pain and to improvements in depression and quality of life. The authors rated the evidence on pain as low quality and called for larger, more rigorous trials.

Read the paper(opens in a new tab)

Heart Health & Blood Pressure

Meditation for the Primary and Secondary Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease

Cochrane Review

This review looked at meditation for people at risk of, or living with, heart disease. Compared with no intervention, mindfulness programs probably reduce stress and may also lower anxiety, depression and blood pressure. Transcendental Meditation may lower blood pressure too. There was very little data on hard outcomes such as heart attacks.

Read the review(opens in a new tab)

Meditation and Blood Pressure: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials

Shi et al. · Journal of Hypertension · 2017

This analysis pooled randomized trials of different meditation styles. Diastolic blood pressure fell by roughly 4 mmHg with Transcendental Meditation and roughly 2 mmHg with other forms of meditation.

Read the abstract(opens in a new tab)

Brain & Cognition

Mindfulness Practice Leads to Increases in Regional Brain Gray Matter Density

Hölzel et al. · Psychiatry Research: Neuroimaging · 2011

A Harvard / Massachusetts General Hospital MRI study. People new to meditation were scanned before and after an 8-week mindfulness program and compared with a waitlist group. The meditators showed gray matter increases in brain regions involved in learning, memory, emotion regulation and perspective-taking. The researchers described these findings as preliminary.

Read the paper(opens in a new tab)

Mindfulness Meditation Improves Cognition: Evidence of Brief Mental Training

Zeidan et al. · Consciousness and Cognition · 2010

After only four 20-minute sessions, people trained in mindfulness outperformed a comparison group (who listened to an audiobook) on tests of working memory, executive function and visual-spatial processing. The gains were largest on timed tasks.

Read the paper (PDF)(opens in a new tab)

Immune System & Inflammation

Mindfulness Meditation and the Immune System

Black & Slavich · Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences · 2016

The first systematic review of randomized trials measuring immune markers in meditators. It found possible effects on inflammation, cellular immunity and markers of biological aging. The authors stressed that these results are tentative and need replication.

Read the paper(opens in a new tab)

Social Connection

Mindfulness Training Reduces Loneliness and Increases Social Contact

Lindsay et al. · PNAS · 2019

A randomized trial of a two-week smartphone-based mindfulness program. Participants who learned both present-moment awareness and acceptance skills reported about 22% less daily loneliness and around two more social interactions per day. A version without the acceptance training showed no change, which suggests acceptance is the key ingredient.

Read the abstract(opens in a new tab)

Addiction & Recovery

Mindfulness-Based Relapse Prevention for Substance Use Disorders

Bowen et al. · JAMA Psychiatry · 2014

286 people who had completed addiction treatment were assigned to mindfulness-based relapse prevention, standard relapse prevention or usual care. At one year, the mindfulness group reported less heavy drinking and about 31% fewer drug-use days than the standard relapse-prevention group.

Read the paper (PDF)(opens in a new tab)

Risks & Side Effects

Adverse Events in Meditation Practices and Meditation-Based Therapies

Farias et al. · Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica · 2020

Meditation is generally safe, but not risk-free. This review of 83 studies found that about 8% of participants reported some adverse effect. The rate was lower in controlled experiments (around 4%) and higher in observational studies. The most commonly reported effects were increased anxiety, low mood and unusual thoughts or perceptions, and they sometimes occurred in people with no prior mental health history.

Read the paper (PDF)(opens in a new tab)

How strong is the evidence for meditation?

The strongest evidence supports meditation for stress, anxiety and preventing depression relapse. Findings on sleep, chronic pain, blood pressure and cognition are promising but come from smaller or lower-quality studies. Research on brain structure and the immune system is still at an early stage.

Part 2

Breathwork

Breathwork means deliberately changing how you breathe: slowing it down, lengthening the exhale, holding the breath, or training the breathing muscles. Research on breathwork is younger than research on meditation, but it is growing quickly. Below is a curated selection of key studies and reviews, grouped by area of benefit, each with a short plain-language summary and a link to the paper (free full text where available).

Stress, Anxiety & Mood

Effect of Breathwork on Stress and Mental Health: A Meta-Analysis of Randomised-Controlled Trials

Fincham et al. · Scientific Reports · 2023

The main meta-analysis of breathwork and mental health. Across controlled trials, breathwork was linked to small-to-medium reductions in stress, anxiety and depressive symptoms compared with control groups. The stress analysis included 12 trials and 785 adults. The authors note that most studies had a moderate risk of bias, so the results should be read cautiously, and breathwork may help some people more than others.

Read the paper(opens in a new tab)

Effect of Coherent Breathing on Mental Health and Wellbeing: A Randomised Placebo-Controlled Trial

Fincham et al. · Scientific Reports · 2023

The largest breathwork trial to date. 400 people practised either “coherent breathing” (about 5.5 breaths per minute) or a placebo breathing exercise. Both groups improved in stress, anxiety, depression and wellbeing, but coherent breathing did not beat the placebo. This suggests that part of the benefit may come from simply taking time to sit and focus on the breath.

Read the paper (PDF)(opens in a new tab)

Brief Structured Respiration Practices Enhance Mood and Reduce Physiological Arousal

Balban et al. · Cell Reports Medicine · 2023

A Stanford study comparing three daily 5-minute breathing practices with 5 minutes of mindfulness meditation over one month:

  • Cyclic sighing: two inhales through the nose, then a long, slow exhale.
  • Box breathing: equal counts of inhale, hold, exhale and hold.
  • Cyclic hyperventilation with retention: fast breathing followed by a breath hold.

All practices improved mood and reduced anxiety. Breathwork improved mood more than meditation, and the exhale-focused cyclic sighing worked best, also producing the largest drop in resting breathing rate.

Read the paper(opens in a new tab)

Nervous System & Heart Rate Variability

Effects of Voluntary Slow Breathing on Heart Rate and Heart Rate Variability

Laborde et al. · Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews · 2022

A large review of 223 studies. Slow breathing increased heart rate variability (HRV), a marker of the body’s “rest and digest” nervous system activity. The effect appeared during practice, right after a single session, and after multi-week programs. The authors describe slow breathing as a low-cost, low-tech tool for prevention and as an add-on to treatment, with few expected side effects.

Read the paper(opens in a new tab)

How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Slow Breathing

Zaccaro et al. · Frontiers in Human Neuroscience · 2018

This review looked at slow breathing (under 10 breaths per minute) in healthy people. It found higher HRV and shifts in brain-wave activity associated with calm, focused states. People reported feeling more relaxed, comfortable, energetic and alert, with less anxiety, anger and confusion. The review was based on a small number of qualifying studies.

Read the paper(opens in a new tab)

CO2-Focused Breathing & Panic

Feedback of End-Tidal CO2 as a Therapeutic Approach for Panic Disorder

Meuret et al. · Journal of Psychiatric Research · 2008

People with panic disorder often over-breathe, which lowers carbon dioxide (CO2) in the blood and can trigger dizziness and breathlessness. In this trial, patients used a handheld CO2 monitor to learn slower, shallower breathing that raised their CO2 levels. Panic severity and frequency dropped substantially, and the improvements held at 12-month follow-up. This approach is known as Capnometry-Assisted Respiratory Training (CART).

Read the abstract(opens in a new tab)

Opposing Breathing Therapies for Panic Disorder: Lowering vs Raising CO2

Kim et al. · Journal of Clinical Psychiatry · 2012

74 people with panic disorder were trained, with CO2 feedback, either to raise or to lower their CO2 levels. Both groups improved. This suggests that learning control over your breathing may matter as much as the specific CO2 target.

Read the abstract(opens in a new tab)

Immune Response (Wim Hof Method)

Voluntary Activation of the Sympathetic Nervous System and Attenuation of the Innate Immune Response in Humans

Kox et al. · PNAS · 2014

Healthy men trained for 10 days in a method combining meditation, rapid breathing with breath holds, and cold exposure; a control group did no training. Everyone was then given a bacterial toxin that triggers a short-lived inflammatory response. The trained group released much more adrenaline, produced more anti-inflammatory signals and had a milder inflammatory reaction. The study was small (12 people per group), and it is not yet clear which parts of the method drive the effect.

Read the paper(opens in a new tab)

Blood Pressure

Time-Efficient Inspiratory Muscle Strength Training Lowers Blood Pressure

Craighead et al. · Journal of the American Heart Association · 2021

This is breathing-muscle training rather than relaxation breathing: participants inhaled forcefully through a handheld resistance device. In a double-blind trial, adults aged 50–79 with above-normal blood pressure did 30 breaths a day, 6 days a week, for 6 weeks. Systolic blood pressure fell by about 9 mmHg (from 135 to 126), and most of that drop was still present 6 weeks after stopping. Blood vessel function improved by about 45%. The low-resistance placebo group saw no change.

Read the paper (PDF)(opens in a new tab)

Asthma & Breathing Patterns

Breathing Exercises for Adults with Asthma

Santino et al. · Cochrane Review · 2020

A review of 22 studies with 2,880 participants covering several methods, including the Papworth method, Buteyko, diaphragmatic breathing and yogic breathing. Breathing exercises probably improve quality of life and reduce hyperventilation symptoms. Asthma symptom scores did not clearly change. Participants had mild to moderate asthma, so results may not apply to severe asthma. Breathing exercises are an add-on to, not a replacement for, prescribed asthma medication.

Read the review summary(opens in a new tab)

How strong is the evidence for breathwork?

The best-supported findings are that slow breathing raises heart rate variability and produces a short-term calming effect, and that breathwork leads to small-to-moderate reductions in stress and anxiety. CO2-guided breathing training for panic disorder also has good supporting evidence.

Less settled areas include whether one technique is better than another (or better than a placebo), CO2-tolerance training in healthy people, and the immune effects of Wim Hof-style breathing, which come from small studies.

Safety: please read before practising

  • Never practise breath holds or rapid “power breathing” in or near water, while driving, or while standing where you could fall. These techniques can cause light-headedness, tingling or fainting.
  • Slow, gentle breathing (such as cyclic sighing or slow-paced breathing) is generally considered low-risk for most people.
  • If you are pregnant, or have epilepsy, a heart condition, high or low blood pressure, a respiratory condition, or a history of panic attacks, talk to your doctor before trying intense breathing techniques.
  • Stop any exercise that makes you feel dizzy, anxious or unwell, and return to normal breathing.

Start with a few minutes a day

iSpiro makes a short daily practice easy: a gentle timer with bells, guided breathing patterns and a calendar to keep your streak going.

See how iSpiro works

This page is for general information only and is not medical advice. Meditation and breathwork can complement, but should not replace, professional care. If you are managing a health condition or taking medication, talk to your doctor before making changes to your treatment.